Does Israel Speak for the World’s Jews?

Lila Garrett Denounces IsraelWelcome to CONNECT THE DOTS. I’m your host Lila Garrett and for the first time in my life asking myself the question that has stumped everybody from Socrates to George Carlin for centuries. That question: Who am I?

Oh, I know the statistics. A mother, a grandmother, a friend, a broadcaster….I won’t bore you with the rest of it. But somewhere in the mix I also know I am a Jew. If someone were to say what is a Jew I would have to answer: I don’t know exactly, but I do know it’s at the core of my being. I guess if I were really Socrates or George Carlin I would be able to define it more eloquently. But since I am not one of those penetrating philosophers I just know that when that core is shattered, the next question is, what do I do with the pieces?

It all happened in the last few weeks when three unarmed Israeli teen agers were kidnapped and killed while innocently hiking near Gaza. This hideous crime, we’re told, was performed by Palestinian zealots. We are also told that Israel’s Prime Minister Netanyahu knew that those teen agers were dead 18 days before announcing it.

Instead, Israel made the decision to hold back that information allowing the search for them to go on, building the public’s rage against the kidnappers, again, presumed to be Palestinians. I say “presumed” because Israel, known for its expert intelligence operation, rarely shows this kind of hesitance in naming criminals.

As for the three teenagers, Netanyahu lost no time making it clear that the Palestinians “will pay dearly for this crime”. So far, grim as it is, it’s nothing new. Both sides are forever playing payback in an endless nightmare of violence. As part of that payback, a group of insane Israeli fanatics found an innocent Palestinian teenager and burned him alive.

To be fair, this too outraged Netanyahu. He made a point of blasting that crime as no more acceptable than the murder of the three Israelis. No one, irrespective of what side they are on, will be tolerated for these crimes, he said.

No one apparently, except him…

Because two days later Israel and Gaza were shooting rockets into each other’s territory without letup. They claimed that Hamas, the leading party in Gaza, started it and maybe it did, but the Netanyahu promise to make the Palestinians “pay dearly” hung in the air.

So the rocket barrages grew but the damage was not equal on both sides. Israel has an Iron Dome system, which prevented serious casualties on their side. While, from these initial barrages Israel lost two people –one from friendly fire — Gaza lost 200, including 80 children, four of whom were killed by Israeli guns from a warship while playing soccer at the beach. Cold blooded murder.

Despite Israel’s practice of pre-warning civilians about what area they were bombing next, potential victims had no place to go. They were and are stuck, getting killed like fish in a barrel.

As for the rest of the country, the population is locked in like a jail cell. All one and a half million Gazans are jammed together in a 25-mile sliver of land. So despite Israel’s practice of pre-warning civilians about what area they were bombing next, potential victims had no place to go. They were and are stuck, getting killed like fish in a barrel.

A little history: In 2006 Israel declared Gaza an independent country and to prove they were sincere they called for free elections. But when Hamas won, Israel went crazy. Even when Hamas began its term by holding out a friendly hand in hope of a détente, Israel would have none of it. Instead hostilities became more intense and there have been constant short but lethal attacks ever since.

Each of these bloody sessions has ended with more gothic restrictions on the Gaza population. They are now forbidden by the Israel to leave by sea or to migrate to Egypt or anywhere else. They are not allowed to import or export, This means their economy is not hurting; it’s dead. Jobs are not in short supply, they’re in no supply. As for food and medicines…what are they? The people of Gaza vaguely remember…if they’re lucky.

When weeks ago Egypt offered a deal for a cease fire, Israel agreed to it…but not to the demands of Hamas. Israel then renewed their attacks. Hamas, meanwhile had made demands that even the New York Times felt were surprisingly modest. So modest in fact it’s hard to understand why Israel, if they really wanted peace, would refuse them. Here are the demands of Hamas, straight from the New York Times.

  • the release of arrested Hamas operatives
  • the reopening of the crossing from Gaza into Egypt
  • the reduction of Israeli restriction on the movement of people and goods, and
  • the payment of salaries for Hamas-appointed government employees

Nowhere did Hamas ask for recognition as the elected government of Gaza. But why would they since they refuse to recognize Israel. So that point seems negotiable. Still, they did not even ask for the ability to import and export. They asked for a reduction, not even an end of Israeli restriction on the movement of people and goods. And yet, as minimal as those terms were, the Israelis responded by stepping up attacks on Gaza and its trapped population. Fish in a barrel indeed. How ugly can it get.

Lila Garrett Denounces Israel

Israel Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon and Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Now, after another brief period of quiet, the gloves are off. Israel has launched a full ground attack on Gaza. Why is that necessary? Let’s take some educated guesses based on fact:

  • The fact is that Israel feels the need of more land to extend its wealth, power, and population.
  • The fact is that it will not now, nor will it probably ever tolerate the concept of a two-state solution. Where will the other state come from? The West Bank where Jewish settlements are so plentiful and settlers are so fanatical? Israel would have to fight its own people to pry them out of there. Will this ever happen? Not likely.
  • The fact is that the Palestinians and the Israelis, who once lived peacefully side by side in the same country, had better become one nation again, or they will battle, murder and pillage for the rest of time. You may not like the sect of your neighbor, but you had better tolerate it or resign yourself to endless hurting and killing….as we see in Iraq with Sunni and Shia…who, before we entered the picture, lived very comfortably together.

Most of the rest of the world has learned that lesson. Ask the Irish, ask the So. Africans, ask the nations in the European Union. Ask the United States for God’s sake. We out here in the rest of the world have learned either you live together or you perish together. Will Israel ever accept that reality? This massive attack on Gaza certainly doesn’t look like it.

Because of this exercise in genocide, the legacy of the six million Jews who died in Nazi concentration camps has been mocked. Their deaths have taught us nothing.

With all of this, remarkably, Israel continues to insist it speaks for the Jewish population of the world. That’s a smaller number than you think. There are approximately 6 million Jews in Israel, 5 million in the United States, and about 2 million in the rest of the world. When we say we’re a minority, we mean small. But that doesn’t mean we all agree.

The original premise of this piece was the question: “Who am I?” Let’s change that to who are “we”, because there are millions of us who do agree. We are the same group who have not only had it with Israel’s policy of endless war, we cannot abide its right wing, paranoid leadership.

So who are “we”, the Jews who Israel does not represent. We are progressives, obviously. We are supporters of Peace movements, determined to convert Americas (and Israel’s) permanent war economies into green and consumer economies. We are supporters of enhancing the social programs for which our taxes pay, and we are champions of our Constitution which is in severe danger of being ravaged by our own right wing Supreme Court.

We, the Jews Israel does not represent, are believers that our borders should be open to oppressed people everywhere, including the 25,000 children being deported to their Central American countries where they face violence, despair, and very possibly death. The President dismissed them by saying “some kids have it tougher than others.” A president that cavalier doesn’t speak for us either.

Since Israel proceeded with this genocide against the people of Gaza, I know who I am. I am a person who finally, sadly, recognizes the experiment of Israel as a failure and can no longer support it as a Jewish state or as a democracy.

lila-garrett-200Because of this exercise in genocide, the legacy of the six million Jews who died in Nazi concentration camps has been mocked. Their deaths have taught us nothing. Those who have been victims of genocide should be enemies of it….not promoters of it.

So to the 6 million-plus Jews who live in Israel, we say, if you really want to represent all 13 million of us we urge you to stop using your vote to re-elect hawks fueled by hate like Netanyahu and sadistic agents of death like your Foreign Minister, Lieberman. You and only you can get rid of them. For the sake of your children the children of Gaza, for the sake of all 13 million of us…for simple human decency, vote your masters of war out of office.

Lila Garrett
Connect The Dots

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Comments

  1. Duke thompson says

    thank you for saying this. I have spoke up about what Israel is doing at great risk of losing my Israeli Jew friends. It is impossible for somebody who is not Jewish to speak the truth as you did and not get labeled “anti-semitic” . Thank you for posting this well thought out information.

  2. ReverendDraco says

    By the Gods! A voice of reason!

    This is the first reasonable text I’ve read, during the last few months, from those self-identified as Jews. . . All else has been hatred and vitriol, extending even to those who have denounced the latest round of death and destruction.

    “Anti-Semite” (a more racist term has never been invented) and “Nazi” figure quite prominently, as do calls for such people to be killed.

  3. Babysoft says

    It was like my lungs and chest could expand again when I read this piece. Thank you for the deep breath of fresh air and the feeling that circulation had returned to my being – like their will be support from the very people who can do something to stop this genocide – those with a vested interest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *