My Lesson in Action from the Murder of Kitty Genovese

bicyclistMid-afternoon on Wednesday, driving along a Los Angeles street in the West San Fernando Valley, I saw this man lying on the parkway of the road.

At first, I drove past him because I was driving too quickly to stop. But I turned my car onto the nearest street, made a quick U-turn, and rushed back to him. While I maneuvered back, I noticed no one else was stopping. Drivers glanced over and drove right on by. Two women walked by him as I waited to turn my car. They barely looked at him. They never tried to rouse him or even stop their conversation. They felt no moral imperative to assist him. Conveniently for them he was positioned out of their way.

As I made my u-turn to get to him, and finally park, a bicyclist rode by him, and he, too, never stopped. I watched in amazement as the biker peered down for a second and rode past him. That was it. All pedal – no mettle.

Who are WE in America?? What have WE become?

Americans don’t live in the same war zones we enable and create. This isn’t Iraq or Afghanistan or Gaza or Darfur. In those despairing places, people lie on the street everyday. Of course, in Iraq, Afghanistan, Gaza and Darfur, to name but some of our engineered horrors, blood usually covers their bodies. There was no blood covering this man.

How lucky to be in America!

Still, this man, whom the pedestrians, bikers, and drivers passed by, could have been in diabetic shock, had a heart attack, suffered internal injuries from an accident, been unconscious from his fall, had a seizure, or been just plain drunk. Myriad maladies could have overcome him. Yet his observers carried on despite seeing his body. How different they would feel were that body their own, or that of their loved one. But if it’s not about us or those we personally love, often it just doesn’t matter. We can be that selfish — unless we are predisposed toward compassion, are taught from a previous lesson, or both.

I learned one of my most powerful lessons when I was 14-years-old in New York City. I was horrified by an infamous murder that occurred in 1964 in my borough of Queens. A young woman, Kitty Genovese, was brutally attacked, raped, and murdered, yet her screams for help were casually ignored by most of her own neighbors. For those who don’t know this story, and for those unaccustomed to offering help, here are the gruesome details from Wikipedia that may teach you about taking action when someone else needs help.

Kitty Genovese had driven home in the late night of March 13, 1964. Arriving home at about 3:15 a.m. and parking about 100 feet (30 m) from her apartment’s door, she was approached by Winston Moseley, a business machine operator. Moseley ran after her and quickly overtook her, stabbing her twice in the back. Genovese screamed, “Oh my God, he stabbed me! Help me!”

It was heard by several neighbors, but on a cold night with the windows closed, only a few of them recognized the sound as a cry for help. When one of the neighbors shouted at the attacker, “Let that girl alone!”, Moseley ran away and Genovese slowly made her way toward her own apartment around the end of the building. She was seriously injured, but now out of view of those few who may have had reason to believe she was in need of help.

Records of the earliest calls to police are unclear and were certainly not given a high priority by the police. One witness said his father called police after the initial attack and reported that a woman was “beat up, but got up and was staggering around.”

Other witnesses observed Moseley enter his car and drive away, only to return ten minutes later. In his car, he changed his hat to a wide-rimmed one to shadow his face. He systematically searched the parking lot, train station, and small apartment complex, ultimately finding Genovese, who was lying, barely conscious, in a hallway at the back of the building, where a locked doorway had prevented her from entering the building.

Out of view of the street and of those who may have heard or seen any sign of the original attack, he proceeded to further attack her, stabbing her several more times. Knife wounds in her hands suggested that she attempted to defend herself from him. While she lay dying, he sexually assaulted her. He stole about $49 from her and left her dying in the hallway. The attacks spanned approximately half an hour.

This horrific, perhaps preventable murder, became a blight on New York and New Yorkers for years. I took it so personally as a teenager that I wished for the longest time I’d been able to save her. Of course, that was impossible since I lived at least 20 miles away. But in those days, murders seemed to have a greater social impact. They were more rare. Only organized crime and militarism were habitual. Individuals tended to take personal responsibility for communities, neighbors, and family – which made the Genovese case an anomaly for its time.

Kitty Genovese

The psychology of the neighbors’ passivity in the Genovese case has been studied for years. The two social phenomena thought by professionals to best describe the neighbors’ inaction are Diffusion of Responsibility and Bystander Effect. I apply both these unfortunate social phenomena to those who oppose war, corporate crime, and other injustices, but take no personal action to stop them. Instead, they want others to fight their fights. Those are the very same people who tell me, and maybe tell you, that they don’t need to be ACTIVE because I’m/we’re ACTIVE for them. The inaction from these dysfunctional social phenomena does not lead to success. It leads to the murders of innocents, endless war, corporate crime, and people lying unattended on our streets. These are the results of their inaction.

In my very lay opinion, the social phenomenon that seems to apply to those who ignored Wednesday’s bicycle man is bystander effect, although callousness and indifference are also distinct possibilities. I personally don’t buy “lack of time” as an excuse in this technological era since anyone can phone for help while driving.

Bystander effect is defined as:

A social psychological phenomenon in which individuals are less likely to offer help in an emergency situation when other people are present. The probability of help is inversely proportional to the number of bystanders. In other words, the greater the number of bystanders, the less likely it is that any one of them will help.

Despite the lack of street traffic shown in the photos, there were plenty of people who saw this young man and chose not to respond. I have no idea how long he was on the street before I saw him, which increases the numbers of those who could have helped. But there is a positive end to his saga.

When I got to the downed man and tapped him on the shoulder, at first he wouldn’t respond. After several nudges he finally came to. He attempted to stand but he couldn’t. I called the paramedics and they arrived within minutes. True to bystander effect, I was the only person who’d called them. The paramedics coaxed him to his feet, spoke with him for a few moments, and sent him off with his bike. He may have been drunk.

I sat for a while and watched him unsteadily amble away. One picture shows the paramedic truck and the still-disoriented man walking up the street with his bike. Why he wasn’t hospitalized for further observation is an issue directed to our health care debate. Clearly this man wasn’t wealthy.

In the end, it doesn’t matter what reason this young man was lying on the street. Be it medical or chemical, I still would have stopped. I refuse to indulge in bystander effect and won’t live in the guilt of inaction. In part, it may just be my nature, but it’s also my lesson from the murder of Kitty Genovese.

linda_milazzo.jpgIt would be hard to imagine any positive outcome from that brutal killing 45 years ago. But if that murder has prevented bystander effect or diffusion of responsibility in those who were offended by the human failings that resulted in Kitty’s death, than Kitty Genovese was a hero whose death may have saved many lives.

Author’s note: I’m remembering another young hero today who should not have been murdered, and whose 30th birthday was April 10th. Happy Birthday Rachel Corrie. We continue your commitment to humanity and peace, and we wish you were with us today!

Linda Milazzo
LA Progressive

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Comments

  1. Andrew says

    I have come across this article due to my searching on the “bystanders effect” I learned of that due to the
    recent event in New York. New Yorkers kept on walking as Hugo Alfredo Tale-Yax, 31, lay dying on a sidewalk
    in the city’s Queens borough. This comment most likely will not be read, but just to clear my head I feel the
    need to write them.

    How to explain why people walked by Hugo Alfredo Tale as he laid on the side walk. I heard someone say that no one saw him bleeding so that is why they did not help. Cause if they saw blood
    that would be change everything. So people will help then, you just need to meet some level of pain…..As if…

    I could explain my take on it and how I would have acted differently. That is what tends to happen when I can
    explain others acts. I have help people before..money, ride, phone call and so on. Why, either I am asked or notice that something is out of place. While I will not say that this is what the world is coming to….I do noticea general lack of people “seeing” what hey are looking at. As for as caring or not….I can’t say.

    Its more of a “not my bussiness” attitude. Be it a box on the floor in a store or a body. People may say that a body is way more important then a box. But I believe the thinking is the same. So the search goes on to fine the words to explain the reason and perhaps open the minds eye. I would not count on it….that is the society we live in. It happened in 1964 ,2010 and the years in between.

  2. Gene Rothman says

    There is no small irony in the fact this insightful piece on American culture by Linda Milazzo has, thus far, received no comments. Just as passersby ignored the victim she responded to, so too are readers averting their eyes and their voices from this article. U.S. citizens appear to have lost not only the capacity for outrage in the face of numerous social injustices, but also for even simple civic decency.
    I would also like to commend this writer for another increasingly rare occurrence: good writing and skillful journalism. From a well-developed historical theme grounded in the Kitty Genovese incident to the literature on the “bystander effect,” Ms. Milazzo brings a mirror of our present state of mind up close and personal. I hope that more people will read and comment on this article and, more importantly, vow to follow in her footsteps the next time they see a fellow citizen in distress.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *