Abolishing Capital Punishment in the United States

Abolishing Capital Punishment in the United StatesAbolishing Capital Punishment in the United States

There’s a buzz about the death penalty in America these days. And nearly all of the conversation focuses not on how to maintain the practice, but rather on abolishing the death penalty.

Connecticut just decided to repeal the death penalty, following the lead of Illinois, New Mexico, and New Jersey in recent years. Meanwhile, a federal judge ruled California’s death penalty unconstitutional.

Faced with the high cost, lack of deterrent effect and the inevitability of executing innocent people, some states are taking another look. Moreover, given the appalling specter of prosecutors striking black jurors and other forms of racial misconduct, North Carolina and Kentucky have enacted racial justice legislation to overturn racially biased death sentences.

With the European Union enacting an export ban on lethal injection chemicals to theU.S., states are scrambling to find out how to kill people. With diminished supplies, states are faced with the option of suspending executions altogether, or like a violence addict, purchasing the poisons on the black market. In other cases such as Ohio, they have abandoned the commonly-used, three-drug protocol in favor of a single drug such as pentobarbital – a more commonly found substance used to euthanize animals.

And so, as people are still put down like dogs in the land of the free – despite the momentum for abolition – capital punishment represents America’s human rights blind spot. But really, this is about more than executions. Rather, it speaks to a nation that often pays lip service to upholding human rights, but debases and denigrates human life through its actions. The result is a callous culture of violence, neglect and disregard.

The U.S. ranked fifth in the world in capital punishment last year, in league with China, Saudi Arabia, Iran and Iraq. A world leader in executions, America is the world’s foremost leader in prisons. The U.S. claims one-twentieth of the global population, but one-quarter of the world’s prisoners. A majority of these prisoners are poor and of color, poorly educated, poorly represented in the courtroom and failed by the system. The warehousing of people is big business, an unseemly union of criminal justice policy and profit motive.

david loveIs it an accident that the world’s prison leader also ranks near the bottom in income inequality, boasts the largest income inequality in the developed world? Hardly not. Inequality in the land of opportunity is far more than in Europe, Canada, Australia and South Korea, but also more than nearly all of Asia, West Africa and North Africa.The top 1 percent of Americans enjoy far more than elsewhere in the West in terms of executive pay and policies favoring the rich. This, as America’s 99 percent receivefar less government support for health insurance, daycare, pensions and education.

Meanwhile, as the U.S. preaches democracy to the rest of the world, it enacts voter ID laws that could potentially disenfranchise millions of citizens. Harder to vote, yet easier to purchase a gun. Leading the industrialized nations in handgun proliferation and firearms deaths, America is truly what Martin Luther King called “the greatest purveyor of violence in the world today.” Lax gun laws, “shoot to kill” legislation and laws allowing concealed weapons in schools, churches, sports arenas and bars reflect the power of corporate arms manufacturers in U.S. politics. Made in America, the violence is exported to Mexico in the form of illegal weapons fueling the drug war carnage.

And this culture of violence extends to the death penalty, in a country conditioned by years of dehumanization, normalized through slavery and Jim Crow lynching. The death penalty is the tip of the iceberg when it comes to human rights violations in the U.S. It might be the most disturbing example of the human rights challenges facing the nation, and the challenges are many.

David Love

Posted: Friday, 18 May 2012


  1. Nashvillekat says

    While researching my new book, “the 80%Solution: Christians Doing the Right Thing,” in a chapter on murder and the death penalty, I found the same thing and that we have more people in prison than China, which has four times the population. I also found that the most religious portion of the country has both the highest murder rates as well as the highest rates of execution. For instance, there have been more than 600 executions in Texas alone since the death penalty was reinstated. In the least religious state in the Union, Massachusetts, there have been four, yet, the state’s murder rate is more than 50% lower than the Lone Star State’s.

  2. Hwood007 says

    I agree, too many mistakes are made in courts that are discovered too late.  Do you know why the other countries you listed have such high rates, it is not because of what we here would allow to be a crime? Those countries have a different list of crimes than we do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *