The Case for Separation of Church and Weather

moche artworkThe Moche lived in northern Peru from about 100-700 A.D. Their molded ceramics are still a highlight in the annals of human accomplishment. If you walk through a museum of pre-Columbian art, it’s easy to spot a Moche piece – the faces are so realistic you expect them to wink at you.

Around 500 A.D., the world was experiencing some drastic climate changes. There was a super El Nino weather phenomenon on the west coast. Cataclysmic floods were followed by drought. The Moche, like most ancient peoples, are thought to be very religious. They wanted to thwart this devastation and improve the weather by trying to appease their gods. So they sacrificed masses of their citizens. Just slaughtered hundreds of people in hopes of saving more.

Does this sound like religious extremism? Yes. Because it is.

Negotiating with nature is a very ancient thing to do:  Pre-science, pre-wheel, – pre-written language. As a species, we’ve always seen patterns in natural events and taken it personally. Floods are because of sin – droughts are because of witches. Earthquakes are God’s anger towards women’s suffrage and Chinese immigration, etc.

But now we know better. At least, some of us do. Sort of. Now we know the Earth’s crust shifts. It always has. All our continents used to be one; scientists refer to as Pangaea.  We know that continuing shift results in earthquakes.  Instead of hurricanes just appearing all of a sudden as a result of moral shortcomings, we can now track them via satellite for days. There is also a growing understanding about how global warming has intensified weather patterns, hurricanes have been made worse by pollution and the extraction process for natural gas known as “fracking” has caused earthquakes.

Yes, we have a greater knowledge of weather and seismic activities than ever before.

So when the East Coast experienced a rare earthquake – there was an archaic response from religious leaders. It wasn’t that these things happen on this planet we all live on – it was because of gay marriage. Rabbi Yehuda Levin told his YouTube audience, “[We] are starting to see the connection.” As if the earth never moved before cake toppers had two grooms.

It’s ghoulish opportunism. Just like in the wake of the quake that nearly leveled Haiti and killed thousands, televangelist Pat Robertson claimed it was because Haitians made a pact with the devil to liberate themselves from slavery 200 years ago. So Robertson’s devil ran an 18th century anti-slavery Caribbean underground railroad? Wouldn’t that be a good thing? He has an odd religion. He also chimed into the “what did we do to deserve a non-fatal earthquake in DC?” discussion by claiming a crack in the Washington Monument meant
something beyond why not to build a 555-foot marble obelisk on swampland.

Then there was a hurricane in the same area within a week. For capitalizing atmospheric interpreters – it’s show time! Presidential candidate Michele Bachmann told a rally in Florida – the state with the highest proportion of elderly (think Social Security and Medicare beneficiaries) and hurricanes in the country – that these events are a warning about government spending.

Because weather is a quid pro quo with God and the Republican Party’s agenda.

It’s time to build a wall (or a levee) between church and weather.

Natural disasters aren’t punishment. And religion isn’t a Doppler radar.

In 1693, the Massachusetts colonists thought a hurricane there marked the Apocalypse. In April 2011, Texas Governor Rick Perry issued an official proclamation for Texans to pray for rain for three days. Rain has yet to come and it’s categorized as a D4 Drought (there is no D5).

tina dupuyWhat does this mean? Nothing. It means church and weather should get a divorce and block each other’s numbers. Since church and state are no longer the same thing – church should secede from climatology.

It’s not for the sake of the weather – it’s really for the sake of the church’s credibility.

Because really, we could stop letting gays marry, eat all our vegetables, never cheat on our spouses and get to church three times a week – it won’t stop the weather…or the world.

Tina Dupuy
Taking Eternal Vigilance Too Far


  1. Adam Eran says

    This is a nice slant on a very old problem. The actual church (as opposed to the World Wrasslin’ Federation church of assholery you’ll see on TV) says that deeds, whether of sacrifice, or paid for salvation, are not primary, and certainly not what God asks for. Think of the almost-sacrifice of Isaac. So saying “Well, I’ve done my commandments, so I deserve salvation” is actually heresy. The name for this is “salvation by works.”

    The official, orthodox Christian belief is in salvation by grace. It’s a gift, not a trade.

    Another example of how offering a quid pro quo to God (look, I’ll kill my firstborn, and five goats for drought relief, but that’s *it*) is really not in the Christian spirit is the parable of the prodigal son. Did he deserve the feast?

    Anyway, I remain astonished that people are so theologically uninformed and spiritually miserable that they would follow these fakers for five minutes. Sad commentary, really…

  2. Joe says

    Climate change in part results from human behavior and so therefore are its consequences, and the IMPACT of earthquakes, hurricanes, etc. also are affected by human behavior (preparation, existence and use of rescue systems, patterns of development, adequacy of housing. . .).
    To the extent that prayer is an exercise which focuses the mind on critical needs, and helps people act wisely, it can help. Likewise, to the extent it is an escape from study and thought and appropriate action, it hurts.

  3. Nate says

    Tina ;

    You are _DEAD_WRONG_ ! .

    God is *VERY* angry and wants us to kill off the neo-cons & gop members who are trying to destroy America and the world….

    Or at least vote them out of office .

    See now / that was simple , wasn’t it ? .

    (I prefer hitting them with sticks until they learn to behave)

  4. marta says

    Very clever article. Made me smile. You are absolutely right, though, Neo-Christian thinking IS as primitive as the ancient South American natives. However, they had an excuse– it was a LONG time ago. And at least they knew about Astronomy, which is more than Europeans knew at that the time–THEY thought the earth was the center of the Universe.

    If there really is a god, then the Bachmann Perry Overdrive is punishment for voting George Bush into office. (You want stupid? I’ll show you real stupid!) What a stunning duo that is– they make Bush appear Jeffersonian.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *