Wheels Falling Off DHS’s Immigration Enforcement Wagon?

dhs wheelsOver the last few weeks, DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano has been on an enforcement tour defending the Administration’s record on border enforcement while criticizing conservative lawmakers’ “enforcement-first” legislative strategy (Napolitano has repeatedly called on lawmakers to stop “moving the goal posts”).  Instead of defending the Administration’s enforcement strategy, however, maybe Secretary Napolitano should take a serious look at the egregious enforcement actions taking place right under her nose. Yesterday in Michigan, ICE agents apparently followed immigrants from their homes to a nearby elementary school where they were dropping off their children.

According to the Detroit Daily News, six ICE agents surrounded Hope of Detroit Academy (an elementary school) last week, trapping parents inside for nearly an hour. ICE left the school area, but later arrested at least two parents in warrantless stops outside the school. According to the Alliance for Immigrant Rights & Reform Michigan (AIR), the fact that ICE was even at the school violates ICE’s own policies:

ICE’s own policies explicitly prohibit these type of intimidation tactics near schools and places of worship, except in extreme circumstances and with prior authorization from headquarters.

Today, roughly 120 people gathered outside the school to protest ICE’s actions and demand a stop to the profiling of Hispanic residents. State Rep. Rashida Tlaib, who attended the protest, criticized the agency for “causing chaos in Metro Detroit’s most thriving community.” AIR director, Ryan Bates, said ICE’s recent action follows a “pattern of abuse.”

In response, ICE issued a statement today admitting that “elements of the operation appear to have been inconsistent with policy and our standards and priorities” and promised to take “appropriate steps” if an internal review reveals that procedures were violated.

Sseth hoyadly, this is hardly an isolated incident. Last month, Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) deported 4-year-old Emily Ruiz, a U.S.-born citizen and resident of New York, to Guatemala after her grandfather was flagged for a previous illegal entry at the airport. According to the family’s lawyer, “a border agent gave Emily’s dad two choices over the phone: she could be held at juvenile facility in Virginia or go back to Guatemala with her grandfather.” Her father, who said he was never told he could come and pick her up, chose for her to return to Guatemala for fear that she would be put up for adoption should she be held in the U.S. Emily has since been returned to her family.

Clearly, surrounding an elementary school and deporting U.S. citizen children is not listed anywhere under ICE’s comprehensive enforcement strategy. And at this point, an internal review of whether agents followed ICE protocol seems like a weak afterthought. Perhaps the Administration needs to spend more time focusing on oversight and smarter enforcement policies—policies that don’t devastate U.S. families and communities—rather than touting a record number of deportations.

Seth Hoy

Immigration Impact


    • says

      Ben, I don’t know if the problem is your approval of illegal conduct by law enforcement agents, sort of an oxymoron thought, or you don’t believe in government by law. One of the great reasons that people fled Britain and other countries to the colonies was to attempt to get away from prejudice, intolerance, unequal justice and monarchy law. In our nation, in using our I assume you may be a citizen, we have attempted and continue to attempt to construct a nation of law in which the citizen is protected from inappropriate and serendipitous actions perpetrated by law enforcement officers. There ia another explanation for your actions: you are pretending ignorance in order to make an obscure point that is still not clear. Please give us more information to clear up the confusion that your comment engenders.

      • in_awe says

        Seriously, you point to this administration’s policy regarding immigration law enforcement and talk about enforcement of the law?

        Where should we start? Obama’s routine lies about whether the letter of the law mandating completion of a border fence along the southern border has been followed? Allowing sanctuary cities to proudly flaunt their lawless behavior and still receive federal funds despite specific legislation prohibiting that from happening. Or what about rules issued by Napolitano directly that ICE should no longer cooperate with local law enforcement in verifying status of arrestees in local custody. Internal guidelines ordering near termination of workplace raids in favor of never pursued cases against employers? Ever hear about how many times an illegal must be caught, detained and “voluntarily returned to the country of origin before DHS will even consider pressing immigration related charges against the person? In TX it average 14 times! Last month DHS issued 17 more exceptions to detaining illegals in this country – effectively implementing portions of the repeatedly defeated proposed legislation granting amnesty to illegals. So, creating de facto amnesty by regulatory fiat in defiance of popular sentiment as shown repeatedly in polls and votes in Congress is a example of righteousness? Good grief!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *