Skip to main content

Census Bureau Maintains the Spirit of 1790

Sharon Kyle: Today, the Census Bureau maintains the spirit of the objectives established in 1879 which was to count everybody - citizens, non-citizen legal residents, non-citizen long-term visitors and undocumented immigrants.

It happens every ten years. The United States conducts a census—a systematic set of procedures we use to count the number of people living in the country. Mandated in Article I, Section II of the U.S. Constitution, the census was established in 1790 as the official method for determining the actual number of people living in the U.S. whether in residential structures, institutions or living unhoused.

Census Bureau Maintains the Spirit

The framers of the Constitution wanted an accurate count because this number would then be used to determine the number of congressional representatives apportioned to each state. From their perspective, this number determined how much political power each state would claim.

The battle for power among the framers was fierce. States that relied on a plantation economy that were heavily populated with slaves. Their representatives insisted that slaves be counted in the census, which would give the south more congressional representation. The northern states didn’t want the slaves counted at all. In the end, a compromise was reached. The 3/5ths Compromise, as it was called, is found in Article 1, Section 2, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution, which reads:

Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons.

The Census Act of 1790 mandated that everyone except untaxed Indians be counted. It states,

“the marshals of the several districts of the United States shall be, and they are hereby authorized and required to cause the number of the inhabitants within their respective districts to be taken; omitting in such enumeration Indians not taxed, and distinguishing free persons including those bound to service for a term of years, from all others; distinguishing also the sexes and colours of free persons, and the free makes of sixteen years and upwards from those under that age;”

In 1868 the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution repealed the 3/5 Compromise thereby including 100% of all formerly enslaved people in the census count. In 1879 a new census act mandated that Indians not taxed (Indians living on reservations or unsettled areas) also be included in the census. With these two changes, the census of 1880 was the first to attempt to count everyone living in the United States.

Today, the Census Bureau maintains the spirit of the objectives established in 1879 which was to count everybody - citizens, non-citizen legal residents, non-citizen long-term visitors and undocumented immigrants. Americans living abroad who are not members of the armed forces or working for the government are not included in the census.

Note: On Tuesday, July 21, 2020, Donald Trump issued a directive to the U.S. Census Bureau to not count undocumented immigrants in the 2020 census. This directive will likely be challenged on constitutional grounds but if it is enforced, the political impact would be significant especially in California, Texas and New York.

Although census data was originally used almost exclusively to determine congressional representation and taxes, today, census data is also used as the basis for determining federal funding allocations, grants, and other forms of support to states, counties and communities.

Every ten years, after the completion of the census the President is required, by law, to report the census results to Congress. These results may change the number of congressional seats in each state. The governors of each state are then informed of the number of seats his or her state is entitled. The state legislatures then redraw the state’s congressional districts.

Congress set the size of the House of Representatives at 435 voting members. As of the last census, each congressional district was comprised of roughly Seven Hundred Ten thousand people.

Here is what is rarely discussed – Some argue that the modern-day Census Bureau maintains the spirit of the Census Act of 1790 even as it applies to the 3/5th compromise.

In her groundbreaking book, “The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness”, author and civil rights attorney Michelle Alexander introduces her readers to a contemporary practice she likens to the 3/5th compromise—Prison Based Gerrymandering.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

For those unfamiliar, the Three-Fifths Compromise was a deal struck between the southern states and the northern states during the 1787 United States Constitutional Convention. To claim a larger population and thereby be entitled to a greater number of congressional representatives and more power, southern states wanted to count slaves as if they were constituents, northern states opposed this idea. They were at a stalemate. To strike a deal the solution they agreed upon was to count three out of every five slaves as people. This gave the Southern states a third more seats in Congress and a third more electoral votes than if slaves had been ignored.

Today, according to Alexander, most states census residence rules require that incarcerated people be counted at their place of incarceration as opposed to their home address. Like the slaves, the incarcerated cannot vote in 48 states.

Mass incarceration, a phenomenon that did not exist in 1790, has resulted in major population shifts. The overwhelming majority of incarcerated people in the U.S. come from urban areas while the prisons are typically built in non-urban or rural areas.

Census Bureau Maintains the Spirit

Census Bureau Projections for 2020 Congressional Reapportionment

This counting practice results in a shift in population from urban center to rural community thereby increasing the political clout of rural communities while decreasing the political clout of urban communities. And, all the while, the incarcerated, almost without exception, have no say.

In addressing the census residence rule and specifically prison-based gerrymandering, the NAACP Legal Defense Fund reports:

Over the last several decades, the percentage of Americans incarcerated in prisons has increased four-fold. Incarcerated persons are often held in areas that are geographically and demographically far removed from their home communities. For instance, although non-metropolitan counties contain only 20% of the national population, they host 60% of new prisons.

In addition, because Latinos and African Americans are incarcerated at three to seven times the rate of Whites, where incarcerated people are counted has tremendous implications for how African-American and Latino populations are reflected in the census, and, consequently, how these communities are impacted through redistricting.

Political districts are based on population size. The number of people in a geographical region determines the number of Congressional, state, and local representatives. When prison-based gerrymandering is employed, district lines redrawn to accommodate new census figures result in large portions of what would have been urban populations being reapportioned to rural counties and distorts democracy.

Because of this practice, urban communities, particularly urban communities of color stand to lose the most. Census figures help determine where government money will go to fund hospitals, school services, public housing, social services, food stamps and other programs. As mentioned, the census figures are also used to determine how many seats each state has in the U.S. House of Representatives. Prison-based gerrymandering may result in the loss of both federal dollars and political representation for districts that are already struggling.

Prison-based Gerrymandering also defies most state constitutions and statutes, which explicitly state that incarceration does not change a residence.

Data gleaned from the 2020 census will be used to help direct $1.5 trillion per year in federal funding for programs like Medicare, Medicaid, Head Start, Title I and the National School Lunch Program. The data is also used to help officials to determine individual and organizational eligibility for these programs.

By counting incarcerated people as residents of the towns where they are confined, those towns stand to receive a benefit that rightfully should go to the community the incarcerated person calls home and where they will ultimately return.

Breakfast Club Biden

Sharon Kyle

Publisher, LA Progressive