Governor Jerry Brown Signs Immigration Bills that Help, Not Hurt, California’s Economy

jerry brownTake note, Alabama. Over the weekend, Governor Jerry Brown signed two immigration bills that seek to boost California’s struggling economy, rather than saddle it and small businesses with costly enforcement programs. Governor Brown signed the “Employment Acceleration Act of 2011” (AB 1236), a bill that prohibits the state from requiring employers to use E-Verify, as well as the other half of California’s DREAM Act (AB 131), a bill which makes college more affordable for undocumented students and “benefits us all,” as Gov. Brown says, “by giving top students a chance to improve their lives and the lives of all of us.”

The first bill, AB 1236, prohibits the state, cities or counties from requiring employers to use E-Verify, an electronic employment verification system that uses employees’ social security numbers to determine work eligibility. Exceptions are made, however, for city or county workers, or if E-Verify is a requirement for particular employers under federal or as a condition for employers receiving federal funds.

While supporters of mandatory E-Verify claim the system will magically open up millions of jobs to American workers, reports find that the program would actually cost California’s small businesses (which make up 99% of employers in the state) more than $312 million per year and potentially put 90,000 U.S. citizen and legal state workers out of a job. Nationally, mandatory E-Verify would cost small businesses $2.6 billion a year, according to Bloomberg News Service, and cost federal contractors $10 billion to implement. According to Assemblyman Paul Fong, AB 1236’s sponsor:

“This bill protects our California workers and businesses. The mandated use of E-Verify would impose a major financial burden on businesses, especially small businesses. In addition, businesses will suffer from delayed hiring and the cost of mistaken identities.  In this tough economy, we need to help businesses and grow and provide jobs, not set up barriers that cost jobs.”

The second bill, AB 131, builds on the first half of the California DREAM Act (AB 130) which allows undocumented students to enroll in California’s public colleges and universities to receive privately-funded university scholarships from non-state funds. AB 131 allows undocumented students to apply for and receive state-based funding, such as, Cal Grants at universities (only after such grants are awarded to eligible documented students), fee waivers, and some types of financial aid administered at the university or college level (such as UC Grants).

seth hoyIn a statement, Gov. Brown said that “the Dream Act benefits us all by giving top students a chance to improve their lives and the lives of all of us.” According to the Public Policy Institute of California, the state will not have enough college graduates to keep up with economic demand by 2025. AB 131, however, could play a critical role in boosting the number of college grads, says the UCLA Institute for Research on Labor and Employment.

With an increasing unemployment rate of more than 12%, California legislators concluded that it “must pursue all avenues in facilitating and incubating job development and economic growth.” Hopefully other states will follow California’s lead by passing bills that grow local economies, rather than hurt local businesses with costly enforcement bills that end up costing American workers their jobs.

Seth Hoy
Immigration Impact


  1. says

    I won’t at this time go into the utter falseness of Seth’s premise that e-verify would put American citizens out of a job. Suffice it say the only jobs at risk are the one’s in which a person cannot earn an living wage and exists today because of the presence of so many eager illegal aliens willing to do the work for a pittance.

    Rather, lets focus the impact to the citizenry. the 2,500 or so households with children (not to mention parents) of US citizens residing here in California that will not be receiving tuition assistance despite their being deserving of it should be consoled by the fact that the resources of the state have gone to aid more deserving non-citizens. How long, how long will our immigration policy continue to be focused on the needs of immigrants over the needs of citizens?

    The answer simply stated is this will continue as long as the corporatocracy is allowed to corrupt the federal and state legislators and keep the door open to for a large and highly exploitable class of labor. The most shameful thing about this is it is done with the complicity of the Democratic Party, the party that holds itself up to be the champion of labor and education for all citizens.

  2. Jack says

    Ain’t that great. California would rather pay for free or cheap college for illegal aliens than help its own citizens get an education. Go liberals! What a bunch of suckers.

    Yup, this bill will certainly help California’s economy and Californians – if you’re a business owner, that is. Especially if you hire illegal aliens so you don’t have to worry about those pesky workplace safety rules, minimum pay, social security, workers compensation and other employer taxes. No worries – the State of California will now help you cheat the system by continuing to hire illegal aliens.

    But if you’re a regular American worker, you’re screwed. Your taxes will now pay for college education for illegal aliens who will compete with you for jobs, and who will take college seats away from your own kids. But, hey, at least the bills will create jobs. Just not for you. Like free trade agreements that “help” the economy (in foreign countries, that is), these bills are a sneaky way to make the rich richer at the expense of the common American.

    You gotta wonder why liberals are so h_ll bent on hurting their own futures. Clueless. These are the kind of naïve, liberal policies that make independents vote for Republicans instead of Democrats.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *