LA Progressive

Smart Content for Smart People

  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us / Copyright Info
    • Privacy Policy
  • Topics
    • Animal Rights
    • Climate Change
    • Economic Justice
    • Education Reform
    • Elections and Campaigns
    • Environment
    • Community Calendar
    • Healthcare Reform
    • Immigration Reform
    • Labor
    • Law and Justice
    • LGBTQ
    • Progressive Issues
    • Social Justice / Racism
    • The Media
    • The Middle East
    • War and Peace
  • Authors
    • All Authors
    • Steve Hochstadt
    • Charles D. Hayes
    • David A. Love
    • Diane Lefer
    • Dick Price
    • Jerry Drucker
    • John Peeler
    • Joseph Palermo
    • Tom Hall
    • Sharon Kyle
    • Sikivu Hutchinson
  • Scorecards
    • California Assembly Criminal Justice Scorecard
    • California State Senate Criminal Justice Scorecard
  • Events
    • Left Coast Forum
    • Event Calendar
  • Subscribe

Masterpiece Cakeshop Case Shows American Decline

Masterpiece Cakeshop Case

 “[D]efendants’ contention that the Act was invalid because it ‘contravenes the will of God’ and constitutes an interference with the ‘free exercise of the Defendant’s religion’” [is “patently frivolous”].

Newman v. Piggy Park Enterprises, Inc., 390 U.S. 400, 403 n. 5 (1968)

Compare what the Supreme Court did in connection with conflicts between religious rights and racial discrimination in 1968 and religious rights and gender discrimination in 2018 and you can see how America has declined.

Compare what the Supreme Court did in connection with conflicts between religious rights and racial discrimination in 1968 and religious rights and gender discrimination in 2018 and you can see how America has declined.

In Newman v. Piggy Park Enterprises, Inc., the petitioners brought a class action on the grounds of racial discrimination against the operator of five drive-in restaurants and a sandwich shop. The defendant lost and yet contested the right to attorneys’ fees. The defendant argued, in part, that the Civil Rights Act was “invalid because it ‘contravenes the will of God’ and constitutes an interference with the ‘free exercise of the Defendant’s religion’.” In an 8-0 decision, the Supreme Court stated that this argument was “patently frivolous.” Newman v. Piggy Park Enterprises, Inc., 390 U.S. 400, 403 n. 5 (1968).

Now compare these words with the Court’s recent decision in Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Comm’n, 584 U.S. ____ (June 4, 2018). Here, a baker refused to prepare a wedding cake for a homosexual couple. His grounds for doing so was that requiring him to prepare the cake violated his religious beliefs and was unconstitutional under the First Amendment. By a 7-2 decision, SCOTUS agreed with him.

Yes, 50 years have elapsed between the two decisions. But supposedly our constitution does not change. So why is it frivolous to argue that one can discriminate racially on religious grounds and not on gender grounds?

Let’s imagine the next case before SCOTUS in 2020, when a taxi driver refuses to permit a gay couple to ride in his cab, arguing that driving for such a couple would violate his religious scruples. And what happens when the taxi driver refuses to drive for a Jewish couple on similar grounds?

It’s one thing to say that people can discriminate on religious grounds when they are in their church. Yes, they can bar black people from crossing their threshold. But once they start engaging in the real world of commerce, they cannot make special rules for themselves.

SCOTUS has permitted special rules exempting churches from taxation. But if it was decided that churches would be taxed in the same way as anyone else, this wouldn’t violate the First Amendment. Churches are taxed on businesses that they own. So a church that sells cakes through a bakeshop can be taxed, but they can violate the rights of their customers by refusing to sell to them? This makes little sense.

Michael Hertz

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

By Michael T. Hertz posted on June 10, 2018

DISCLAIMER: The opinions expressed here are those of the individual contributor(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the LA Progressive, its publisher, editor or any of its other contributors.

About Michael T. Hertz

Born in New York City in 1944, Michael T. Hertz has lived and worked in California, New York, Rhode Island, Maine, Nova Scotia, British Columbia, and France -- mostly as a lawyer and law professor. A graduate of Harvard Law School and Pomona College, he spends his time presently writing fiction, blogging and commenting on the Internet, traveling, doing photography and digital art, making wine and beer, baking bread, doing water and land aerobics, and tending his garden. His writing subjects includes France in the 1960's, post-Civil War America, and present-day California and Canada.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Refugees Begging Entry

Another Brick in the Wall

Royal We

Dear Mister President: The Royal We


The LA Progressive cannot publish without your support. Please donate. Thank you.
Trump Makes Dubya Look Smart

To Brits, Trump Makes Dubya Look Smart

Lance Simmens: “He has no class, no charm, no coolness, no credibility, no compassion, no wit, no warmth, no wisdom, no subtlety, no sensitivity, no self-awareness, no humility, no honour and no grace – all qualities, funnily enough, with which his predecessor Mr. Obama was generously blessed.”





Book-A-Bus



Please CLICK this donate button - we need your support. Thank you, LA Progressive

Article Categories

Africa | Animal Rights | California
Climate Change | Defense | Economic Justice
Education Reform | Elections | Environment
Events | Foreign Policy | Gay Rights
Healthcare Reform | Immigration Reform
Juvenile Justice | Labor | Latin America
Law and Justice | Los Angeles | Prison Reform
Progressive Issues | Science & Religion
Sexism | Social Justice | Terminal Velocity | The Body Politic
| The Media | The Middle East | Veterans
War and Peace | Wellness

The LA Progressive cannot publish without your support. Please donate. Thank you.

Los Angeles

LA County Construction Vote

L.A. Jail Vote: Wrong Side of History

Peter Laarman: Everyone in the auditorium on today could smell the bad faith in the comments of supervisors Barger, Hahn, and Ridley Thomas.

More Posts from Los Angeles

The Middle East

Anti-Semitism Claims

Don’t Let Bogus Claims of “Anti-Semitism” Derail the Pro-Palestinian Movement

Jim Lafferty: The pro-Israeli lobby is rapidly losing its propaganda campaign aimed at silencing those who dare to criticize the bad behavior of the Israel government.

More Posts from The Middle East

Economic Issues

Forex Market

How to Get Started in Forex Market

Daffa Zaky: Probably the number 1 thing you need to understand is to learn the basics first. Forex markets can grow complex as you invest more in the market.

More Posts from Economic Justice

Copyright © 2019 · Dick Price and Sharon Kyle · Log in