Book Burning and the New Red Scare

religious intoleranceWhile things are looking deservedly bleak for a Democratic Congress that has spent the past two years wallowing in an institutionalized contempt for any form of progressive action, the Republican Party has, in the past couple of weeks, made clear that its obeisance to the most short-sighted, crassly commercial and hypocritical business interests will yield policies in the new Congress, after the mid-term elections, that will easily reveal the Republicans as even more dysfunctional than the Democrats.

Some may have thought that the Beck-Palin rally, to reclaim August 28 from its association with Martin Luther King, Jr. and civil rights, represented the lowest point in the Party’s self-degradation. But such was not the case. Last week, Bill Keller, an online televangelist, bragged that he had the closest ties to Satan, and access to Satan’s plans for America, of any of the religious right leaders. And this week, Terry Jones, the for-profit Prophet of a Florida church that preaches that Jesus was wrong about almost everything he said, came out proclaiming that his desire for personal gain and fame was more important than the safety of our troops in Afghanistan, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, and all the other places we station them.

The Republican Party has embraced the movement to demonize Moslems with the same fervor with which it embraced the Beck-Palin program of “restoring honor” to the glory days of night-riding, segregated lunch counters and no citizenship for brown babies born in the United States. These are the people who will be unified in saying “no,” for the next two years, to any effort to build us out of the depression.

But in their excitement about the success of their excess, we are now seeing the beginnings of the internal divisions that will inevitably push people away from Republicanism as the Bush presidency finally did.

The Dove Worldwide Outreach Center, in Gainesville, Florida, was spearheading a Republican move to burn copies of the Quran. Prophet Terry Jones preaches that the Christian God and Christian Scriptures do not have the power to enlighten people, when in the presence of the Quran. To Prophet Terry, the Quran is Kryptonite to Christianity. He is terrified that if people actually read the Quran, they will be unable to retain their Christian faith.

This fear seems very much the sort of thing that is preached by Fred Phelps of the odious, but Republican, Westboro Baptist Church. Phelps preaches that Christian faith is powerless to survive in a world that also contains homosexuals. Phelps preaches that U.S. troop deaths in colonial wars are God’s punishment for not slaughtering gays here at home. The Dove Worldwide Outreach Center supports Phelps’ homophobia campaigns with even greater zeal than the Republican Party’s support of Prophet Terry’s plan to burn Qurans.

Over Labor Day weekend, while Republicans were disparaging the role of labor in our economy, General David Patraeus, formerly a hero to Republicans, spoke out about the troops who are laboring in Afghanistan. Patraeus said that organized public burning of the Quran would put our troops at risk. He said that such acts made the work of colonial domination harder for our military.

This announcement only spurred Prophet Terry on. In lock step with Fred Phelps’ preaching that every U.S. troop death is a good thing, Prophet Terry responded to Patraeus’ speech by announcing that the book burning will proceed. (He has since waffled on this decision. – Ed.)

The Republican Party takes the position that the campaign to demonized Moslems, by burning sacred texts and lying about the Park51 Center, is more important than the mere safety of any of our troops in the field. The pre-campaign campaign activity of the Beck-Palin ticket, the frontrunners for the 2012 Republican nomination, centers on Islamophobia.

There isn’t any Christian component to this. Rather, it is another effort to find a group which can be demonized, for political and economic gain. In the 1840s and 50s, the Irish bore the burden. Then the Catholics and southern European immigrants. On the West Coast, the Yellow Peril served the same purposes that anti-Irish, anti-Italian, anti-Catholic, etc. bigotry served in the East. These people were all demonized as subhuman invaders, threatening the values and traditions of “real Americans.”

In the 1920s, the Red Scare introduced “The Communists” as new demon invaders. They were accused of attempting to destroy the U.S. by forcing such things as child labor laws, health and safety laws, and limits on adulterated foods. In the 20s and 30s, and into the 50s, unions became the enemy, with their evil plans to get workers living wages, safer workplaces and real retirement plans.

The last half of the 20th century saw the greatest threat to the U.S. as those uppity coloreds began to demand an end to segregation, actual schools for their children, and even such “white” privileges as voting rights and political participation. With the development of the “southern strategy” in the 1970s, the Republican Party has been on a consistent campaign to roll back the gains of the civil rights movement and re-restrict the rights of non-whites.

Finding groups to demonize is a commercial need. Historically, each group that has been demonized is a group which could either be underpaid, underprotected or workers whose fair pay and decent benefits come out of the profits of industry owners. The demonization isn’t driven by any substantive belief, but rather by greed.

But, when the possibilities for gain get too great, the people who benefit from bigotry start to tear at each other, to maximize their gains. So, Pat Robertson’s 1988 Presidential campaign foundered as competing religious businessmen worried that Robertson’s success could cut into the profits they milked from their flocks, and they withdrew support for Robertson.

In this context, the Beck-Palin campaign kick-off has been followed by signs of increasing competition and discord between groups seeking to grab the profits possible from exploiting new fears and hate. The eagerness to target the Park51 project spawned the plan to burn Qurans, with its crass marketing of hate t-shirts and other fundraising “outreach”. But the Beck-Palin folks don’t want to share the profits of demonization. So at least Palin opposes the Quran bonfire.

To avoid political competition, Beck-Palin have had to make laughably insincere claims that their pre-presidential campaign is really religious, not political. This has renewed the commercial competition that sank the Robertson campaign. Televangelist Bill Keller came out swinging, pointing out that Beck, as a Mormon, doesn’t believe in the Christian God and probably has very different ideas about what is honorable than most Christians have. Keller’s opening salvo shows that the commercial religious establishment won’t roll over and yield their profits to the Beck-Palin machine.

This is good news for democrats and progressives, despite two years of squandered opportunity. The new Congress will see Republicans like John Boehner, driven by pure greed, fighting with racist nutballs like Rand Paul, seeking an end to the14th Amendment. After the first blush of euphoric celebration, commercial pragmatism will butt heads with Tea Bag bigotry.

We have seen this before. As I noted in an essay last April, the 1850s “Know Nothing” movement swept the nation, taking state and congressional offices, but then disintegrated almost overnight in an orgy of trying to profit from their ascendency. We will see a repeat of this, starting the day after the November elections.

tom_hall_2.jpgThe Republicans have made refusal to govern a centerpiece of their campaigns this year. But no matter how angry voters are, they want government. When the Republicans forced government gridlock in the 1990s, the voters turned on them. As the new Tea Bag Republicans virtually guarantee gridlock and a forced double dip depression, the voters will again turn on them, giving a chance, in 2012, to candidates who offer real solutions, real progress, real hope. If we can find any.

Tom Hall


  1. Fred Farkle says

    Quote: “…. the Republican Party has … made clear … its obeisance to … commercial and … business interests”

    True. That makes them almost identical to the Democrats. Almost as corrupt. Almost as completely self-serving. Time to kick them all out and put in new representatives who will actually carry out their oaths to uphold the U.S. constitution.

    Quote:” The Republican Party has embraced the movement to demonize Moslems…”

    Completely False. If some of our leaders, Republican or otherwise, have finally awakened to the great danger of the Islamist aggressions and their despicable Sharia law, then that is a good thing. No demonization of individual Muslims is required to recognize the hatred and destruction of the the Islamist hordes who oppress all other Muslims as well.

    Quote:”The Dove Worldwide Outreach Center, in Gainesville, Florida, was spearheading a Republican move to burn copies of the Quran.”

    False Again. One nutbag preacher merely threatens to burn a book and you demonize all Christians and Republicans. What was that you were saying about demonization a little earlier? Hypocrite much?

    It’s true that the Westboro Church is indeed odious. Quit trying to smear the Republicans with your false demonizing. No decent person of any political party supports the nutbags and you know it.

    Quote: ” … the Beck-Palin ticket, the frontrunners for the 2012 Republican nomination, centers on Islamophobia.”

    Deliriously False! Ha ha ha! There you go again with your hypocritical demonizing. And now you’ve gone off the deep end into your own fearful fantasy. That’s pathetic. You are a sick man. Get help, please.

    Quote: “The Republicans have made refusal to govern a centerpiece of their campaigns this year.”

    False, false, false. The Republicans have offered many sensible proposals – all completely shut down by the corrupt lawless Dems, and ignored by the press. The Repubs have fought against the destruction and wreckage and national bankruptcy that the insane out-of-control Dems are singlehandedly imposing.

    So they are doing the best they can in the opposition. But, if they turn back to corrupt self-dealing after winning in November, they also will get kicked out, and we the people will run even more candidates who will abide by the the principles of the Constitution.

    Quote: “But no matter how angry voters are, they want government.”

    Well, what the people actually want is LIMITED government – like our founding Fathers intended in the Declaration of Independence and the Constituion. We want much smaller government, much less expensive government, much less tyrannical and oppressive government. We want that whether an elephant or a donkey happens to be on top at the moment over there in Washington DC. And we’re going to get it. If it saves the lobbyists and the pols from completely imploding at the same time it saves us, well that’s OK too I guess.

    And Tom Hall : after a crazy, nasty, hypocritical, race-baiting, hatred-inciting rant like this – you don’t deserve any label so honorable as “progressive”.

    What you’ve put out here is nothing but cheap demagoguery, and you should be ashamed of yourself.

  2. sandbur says

    It’s not the people who don’t believe in God that worry me, it’s some of the people who do.

    Fundamentalism is the enemy worldwide, no matter what the strain.

    Science flies you to the moon,religion flies you into a building!

    I have always known that the Antichrist will be a “Good Christian”.

  3. says

    The political-religious right is wrong to count their chickens before they hatch. There is plenty of time for a game changing event that will completely blow them all of the water. What if devastating new proof that all three so-called “faiths of Abraham” are purposeful lies. Many know this, but the proof I have just published is the silver bullet and stake through the heart necessary to destroy certain ancient lies.

    Without Christianity, where will the political-religious right be?

    Here is Wisdom…

  4. says

    “The Dove Worldwide Outreach Center, in Gainesville, Florida, was spearheading a Republican move to burn copies of the Quran. Prophet Terry Jones preaches that the Christian God and Christian Scriptures do not have the power to enlighten people, when in the presence of the Quran. To Prophet Terry, the Quran is Kryptonite to Christianity. He is terrified that if people actually read the Quran, they will be unable to retain their Christian faith.”

    Sorry, Jones wasn’t spearheading a Republican move, Sarah Palin was quick to diss him along with Republican leaders. Yes, the Quran teaches that the belief that God had a son is blasphemy against Allah, who condemns them to Hell. I don’t know about Kryptonite,but the Bible and Quran are in an eternal war, no question about it. If it were just a religious issue, who cares that Muslims have regularly burned Bibles they confiscated from Christians, and the Saudi govt. does it every day? Who cares if Christians burn Korans? Both are just books of mumbo-jumbo about gods and the afterlife, right? Wrong, the Koran goes beyond religion to politics, demanding believers to conquer the world for Allah and take over the land and govt. and set up his Sharia that makes Muslims superior to non-Muslims and men to women, and is totally anti-freedom. So maybe you should read it first then see if you can keep from destroying it yourself. Yes, the Old Testament condones slavery and suppression of women, and the New Testament too in a milder form, but Christianity and Judaism went through reformations, and Islam still hasn’t, because of the repeated assertions of the Koran that Muhammad was the final prophet and it must all be submitted to or else other Muslims have a license to treat you as an infidel too.

    Take the Historyscoper’s free online Islam history course and learn all about Islam, its history, ideology and terminology at your own pace, and know rather than guess:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *