Can Democrats Be Patriots?

If you listen to conservative politicians, you might think that voting for Democrats is an unpatriotic act. Mainstream Republican politicians say that liberals are ruining the country and hint that they don’t really have the best interests of our country at heart.

Further out at the right fringes, there is less restraint: liberals are actually socialists trying to destroy America. President Obama is the lightning rod for these accusations of treachery – he is really an African-born Muslim doing his incompetent best to destroy capitalism and deliver us to his terrorist friends.

Nothing new there. Richard Nixon got into the Senate in 1950 by painting his liberal Democratic opponent, Helen Gahagan Douglas, as a traitor, “pink right down to her underwear”, whose real allegiance was to the Soviet Union.

It’s nonsense, and here are two examples to prove it – my father and my father-in-law, both lifelong liberal Democrats, both patriots.

My father, Ernst Hochstadt, came to this country when he was 18, narrowly escaping the Nazis in his native Vienna. He lost his accent, learned to love baseball, and became an American. Everyone called him Ernie, unthinkable in formal European society.

He also became a Democrat. From him and my mother I learned to support the struggle of African Americans for equal rights, symbolized for us by the Brooklyn Dodgers’ star Jackie Robinson. I learned from them that women were as good as men, that labor unions protected the rights and livelihoods of workers, that government should help those in need.

These lessons didn’t come in political lectures. My father was quiet about his beliefs, like he was quiet about having volunteered for the US Army so he could go back to Europe as an officer to fight the Nazis.

My father’s allegiance to his adopted homeland and the freedom it offers was based on his own experiences of tyranny and persecution.

Unlike my immigrant father, my father-in-law, Roger Tobin, personifies the red-blooded American. A lifelong athlete, he delighted in beating all comers at tennis, badminton, basketball, and any other sporting endeavor. His infectious good humor made him a great salesman, who rose through the ranks of his company to become President at the end of his career. He snuck into the Marine Corps at 17 after Pearl Harbor and ended up in Japan.

Roger was a proud Democrat, who wore his liberalism on both sleeves. His financial success put him into the company of lots of rich Republicans, with whom he loved to argue. He never let his friends forget Richard Nixon’s disgrace.

Roger came from a Democratic family. His mother became a social worker during the Depression to help make ends meet and to help those who were even needier. His liberalism came out of the experience of seeing how government could make people’s lives better in hard times.

For Roger and Ernie, liberalism and patriotism were the same thing. They loved the US because the liberal ideals of equality and fairness are at the heart of the American story. They voted for Democrats as an expression of patriotism.

John F. Kennedy expressed their kind of liberal love of country during his campaign for President in 1960, describing his own view of a liberal, when his Nixon tried to tarnish him with that label: “someone who looks ahead and not behind, someone who welcomes new ideas without rigid reactions, someone who cares about the welfare of the people — their health, their housing, their schools, their jobs, their civil rights, and their civil liberties — someone who believes we can break through the stalemate and suspicions that grip us in our policies abroad, if that is what they mean by a Liberal, then I’m proud to say I’m a Liberal.”

Although they disagreed with Republicans, I can’t remember ever hearing Roger or Ernie imply that their fellow citizens with more conservative beliefs were unpatriotic. To them, that would have been un-American.

Steve Hochstadt
Taking Back Our Country 


  1. says

    They might not have said that their fellow citizens who were Republican were unpatriotic, but I will.  When I was traveling to campuses as an antiwar Vietnam veteran, the “conservative patriots” would start heckling me and I’d shut them down every time by asking their leader when was he – as a such a serious patriot – going to quit school, drop his deferment and volunteer to go to Vietnam in the infantry.  They always shut up then.

    Think of Dick “I had other priorities” Cheney, who took five deferments.  George W. Bush, who couldn’t even serve out his whole term of service avoidance in the Texas Air National Guard and deserted. Willard Romney who “desperately wanted to serve” except when he was taking his Mormon missionary deferment that he only got because his family was so high in the church heirarchy.  Name a wingnut who served in the war he claimed he supported.  Then check out John Kerry, who didn’t have to go and volunteered for combat (and all the Swiftboat Liars’ lies have been demonstrated to be lies).  Forget asking if they are patriotic, they are ALL traitors.

    As my great-grand-uncle, who was First Sergeant in Captain Harry Truman’s artillery battery at the Meuse-Argonne and who worked forJudge, Senator and President Truman the 30 years after that said 50 years ago: “the only ‘good Republicans’ are pushing up daisies.” Go read Doris Kearns Goodwin’s “No Ordinary Time” and see what “patriots” the Republican were 75 years ago. They haven’t changed, other than to become more obvious.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *