The Speaker’s Heavy Hand

Money and Power
Portantino represents a mostly wealthy, mostly white district stretching from Pasadena to Glendale to northern LA that has traditionally sent Republicans to Washington and Sacramento. As the single, lonely Democratic voice on the Republican-controlled La Cañada Flintridge City Council early in his political career, Portantino cut his teeth learning to compromise across the aisle, demonstrating a flexibility that helped him get elected to the Assembly in 2006. Hence the independent stance he took with him to Sacramento.

Rules Chair Nancy Skinner

Rules Chair Nancy Skinner

John Perez represents the same overwhelmingly Democratic, light-voting, recent immigrant neighborhoods that once supported former Speaker Fabian Nunez. Instead of experience with the give and take of elective office, Perez’s background is in labor organizing, making “solidarity” his watchword.

Little wonder the two men have bumped heads from the start.

“I worked well with past Speakers Fabian Nunez and Karen Bass. They didn’t always agree with me, but I knew I could walk in their offices, look them in the eyes, state my views, and be respected,” Portantino says, though it should be noted that Bass removed him from his coveted Higher Education Committee chairmanship. “That’s not so with Speaker Perez. He wants everyone to do everything his way—100% obedience.”

Last December, Perez called Portantino to tell him that he was taking away his Revenue and Tax Committee chairmanship, which set this year’s budget clash in motion. “He said I was too outspoken and then threatened further measures if I didn’t fall in line.”

After voting against the budget and then learning of the severe cut in his budget, Portantino  asked to see the budgets of the other 79 members through a public records act request. To date, Portantino says he has not received the records.  Shortly after that request was filed,  the Pasadena Star-News reported:

The Rules Committee on July 14 denied a Star-News Legislative Open Records Act (LORA) request seeking the spending records of all 52 Democrats in the state Assembly. The denial issued by Rules Committee Administrator John Waldie said the state open records act exempts certain materials, including correspondence and legislative memos from disclosure by the legislature.

“So much for transparency in government,” Portantino says.

Principle over Expediency
If the battle really isn’t about the relatively small budget differences, nor his race for Congress, as Portantino posits, where’s the rub?

Portantino contends that Perez, working through Nancy Skinner’s Rules Committee, went after him after he failed to fall in line with the Party’s leadership on legislation involving prison reform, cutting redevelopment agencies, and then in the recent state budget votes.

“You know you’re in trouble when a Berkeley activist tells you to sit down and shut up,” Portantino says of his run-ins with  Skinner.

As one example, Portantino cites his opposition to a prison reform initiative  that would have transferred more prisoners to county jails, where they would have been released.

“California has a 70% recidivism rate, one of the worst in the country,” he says. “Why release prisoners without first teaching them a trade like our prisons used to do? That’s just a revolving door that isn’t good for the prisoners and isn’t good for their communities.”

In its place, Portantino has introduced a measure (AB 219 Prison Reform) that would require the Department of Corrections to reduce recidivism by 20% over the next four years—something akin to the stellar parole reforms in San Francisco that got Kamala Harris elected State Attorney General—legislation he thinks will have little chance of advancing against the Speaker’s opposition to anything Portantino might propose.

On the recent budget bill that the Assembly passed only to meet Governor Brown’s veto, Portantino held out for a full public review.

“The Speaker said that we’re done negotiating with the Republicans and we’ll vote on the budget bill tomorrow,” Portantino says. “I asked, what’s the rush?”

“We pass these budget bills without public scrutiny, without adequate legislative review,” Portantino continues. “Once they’re passed, we find all these problems and have to pass new legislation to fix the mistakes.”

Portantino and Perez

Portantino and Perez (Sacramento Bee)

“That 500-page prison reform bill we passed in a rush? We’ve already had five cleanup bills to fix mistakes we made.”

But legislator pay was going to end the next day, so the Speaker insisted on a vote, which Portantino voted against. Ironically, the bill passed the Assembly by 10 votes, making Portantino’s demurrer irrelevant legislatively.

Going Forward
In talking with the Glendale News Press, Dan Schnur, director of USC’s Jesse M. Unruh Institute of Politics, said that although budgets for any member can vary widely and that the Assembly’s leaders often make closed-door budgeting decisions, the $67,000 they’ve dinged Portantino’s budget seems extreme:

“[Portantino] would have to be taking office staff on Caribbean cruises to be that far over budget. Not only is this retribution, but it’s the harshest example of this type of payback I’ve ever seen. Usually they just move you to a smaller office and let you stew in a corner,” said Schnur.

“There’s no other plausible explanation:  He’s being punished for his budget vote pure and simple, and the leadership is entitled to do that,” Schnur continued. “There’s no rule against it, but it raises questions about depriving members of [Portantino’s] district of the representation to which they’re entitled.”

It’s hard to see how this controversy will help Portantino in his race against long-time incumbent Republican David Dreier’s 26th Congressional District seat, though possibly voters will be attracted to someone willing to take a stance and stick to it.

“I just want to do what’s right for my district and my staff,” Portantino continues. “A decade ago, you had strong committee chairs who would take charge of their legislation. Now, the Speaker has complete and total control.”

Portantino says that many Assembly members are dissatisfied by the rigid, top-down management, but confine their complaints to private grumblings and dare not rally to Portantino’s defense.

“I’m a pretty easy-going guy. I get along with most everyone,” Portantino says. “But I’m also a Jersey boy. I’m not going to be bullied.”

Dick Price & Sharon Kyle


  1. john vollbrecht says

    I agree with Ms. Tucker. Like Leo McCarthy, Anthony is a battler. And believes in transparency.
    Speaking of, or the lack thereof, I remember when the name John Waldie was an honorable name in Democratic Party circles.. Remember Walk with Waldie? I guess nowadays, it’s “March with Perez”–
    or else.

  2. says

    One salient point speaks volumes about Tony Portantino’s integrity: he is the only legislator to have his home phone number listed on his website.

    That says it all. He’s not afraid of his own constituents.

    He’s a legislator of exceptional courage.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *