Willful Deafness to Occupy Wall Street

occupy wall street arrest I’m told the best thing about having a hearing aid is being able to turn it off; selectively, of course, around boring or annoying people. When someone wants to ask you for money. When you’d just like some quiet. There’s a switch. You have the power to tune voices out.

Which is what the media have been doing to the Occupy Wall Street protesters.

The demonstrators have said they want “economic justice.”

And inevitably a talking head will wonder: “What do they want?”

The demonstrators will say they want economic justice.

Then an anchor will say, “There’s not really a cohesive theme with these protesters.”

The demonstrators will march with signs that plainly read they want economic justice.

Then a reporter will offer: “There’s not really a central message permeating in the crowd.”

Yes, the media have gone “Grampa with a telemarketer” on Occupy Wall Street.

That hasn’t hindered the Occupiers from resonating with Americans. The protests have been growing. The movement has been growing. Occupy LA is down the street from my home. Their numbers have nearly quadrupled from the first week. They now count 253 tents at City Hall and have the blessings of the City Council to stay as long as they need. It’s hard to confirm reports of all the other Occupations, it’s rumored to be in the hundreds. I can verify 24 demonstrations across the U.S. where they are “occupying.” There could be dozens more by the time you read this. People from all walks of life are taking to the streets to cry out for “economic justice.”

Now the local news will report: “The demonstrators don’t have any specific unifying points so far.”

Former Speaker of the House Tip O’Neill coined the phrase, “All politics is local.”

tina dupuyAlso, all politics is personal. The housing crisis took peoples’ homes. Families have been uprooted and kicked around by giant soulless corporations. There’s nothing more personal than putting a family’s furniture on the lawn. There’s nothing more personal than seeing “bank foreclosure” signs all in a row in your neighborhood. There’s nothing more personal than witnessing your community, already struggling in the last decade, thrown further by indecipherable market-speak terms like “derivatives” and “securitized mortgage bundles.”

And then there are the students: the victims of direct-to-consumer student loans. And, yes, it’s personal. Education prices have gone up but the federal loan programs’ maximum amount have not. So kids with no means to pay for college other than borrowing, are being forced into paying credit card-like interest on their education with loans that are non-dischargeable in bankruptcy, with no statues of limitations, and can’t be refinanced. These students carry signs reading, “Debt is slavery.” It’s more like sharecropping, which is slavery while being told you’re free.

And there’s the unemployed. They’re the nation’s statistics now donning Guy Fawkes masks. They are the “lagging indicators” who are tired of being called lazy. They want to work and can’t. Those who can’t find work don’t care about the circular firing squad in Washington of everyone blaming everything on whatever side they oppose. For the unemployed, it’s also personal.

Politicians won’t take personal responsibility for the crisis – and so Occupy Wall Street has no choice but to be nonpartisan. Or just bipartisan in their frustration.

It’s the least partisan political movement I’ve witnessed. The phrase Glass–Steagall gets thrown around at Occupy Wall Street like the Volstead Act did at speakeasies. Glass–Steagall, was signed by Franklin Roosevelt in 1933 and made much of what the banks did to tank the economy then (and now) illegal. The Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act also called Financial Services Modernization Act of 1999 basically repealed Glass-Steagall. It was passed by a bi-partisan vote in the Republican-controlled Congress and was signed by Democratic President Bill Clinton.

The Republican George W. Bush then “destroyed capitalism in order to save it.” And President Obama, with his mandate for change, and an entire nation hoping for accountability – hasn’t brought any banksters to justice or re-regulated them in any meaningful way.

tina dupuyAny call for “economic justice” that is also hyper-partisan is disingenuous.

And still someone with overly bleached teeth on television will remark, “Personally, I just don’t understand what these people are trying to say.”

Turn your hearing aid back on, Gramps.

Tina Dupuy
Taking Eternal Vigilance Too Far

Photo by Ross Wolfe


  1. in_awe says

    “That hasn’t hindered the Occupiers from resonating with Americans. The protests have been growing. The movement has been growing.”

    Actually, the protest doesn’t resonate with the average American. The growth in this “movement” can be attributed to SEIU and some other unions joining with the professional protestors, along with the now fully documented paid protestors who are as clueless why they are there as are the “leaders” of the protests.

    The average American is more likely to react to the GM union spitting in the eye of the GM management for offering their $58/hour workers an insultingly low “bonus” of $5,000. Hey, what about the taxpayer getting a “bonus” – or at least our money back before workers whose jobs were saved by our taxpayer money. And no, GM did no “repay” the TARP money – they just shifted around which account the federal taxpayer money is held in without actually repaying the money net-net.

    College kids screaming about economic equity is humorous when they are living off the public teat. The totality of the demands posted on the OWS web site can be covered by a blanket “you’ve got it and we want it – NOW!”. With real unemployment running above 15% in most of the nation, the average American doesn’t want to hear from these lily white crowds demanding more so they can do less.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *